Images from the James Webb Telescope Actually Confound All Theories About Planet Formation

The new images made available by the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) have thrown into confusion all existing theories of planet formation. The dramatic photos capture a stellar assembly within the NGC 346 cluster seen in the Small Magellanic Cloud near our Milky Way galaxy. The photos from the JWST oppose all those previously thought about how planet creation works.

The images show a much bigger number of protoplanetary disks-the swirling rings of gas and dust that orbit young stars as planets are being formed-surrounding rather old stars in NGC 346. Previous models postulated that disks, which are critical to the planet-formation process, would dissipate quickly. JWST's eyes indicate that such disks actually last for a much longer time than previously considered, and that question would eliminate all accepted and historical concepts of time and mechanisms of planet formation.

This longevity directly contradicts the existing theory that a high abundancy of heavier elements is an absolute prerequisite for planet formation. In comparison with our own galaxy, the Small Magellanic Cloud has considerably lower concentrations of heavier elements. This means that the long-lived protoplanetary disks exist in a metal-poor environment, which again contradicts previous models.

Two hypotheses mainly concern scientists now investigating this puzzle. One believes that radiation pressure on these disks is weaker than models predict so that it is slower to dissipate. Another speculation is that initial gas clouds from which stars and disks formed were much more massive than previously estimated and consequently provided a more abundant reservoir to feed the disks for longer durations.

These observations from JWST are much done to promote our basic understanding of planet formation. The absence of short-term lifetimes for protoplanetary disks in the Small Magellanic Cloud calls for changes to existing models and possibly delivering novel ideas regarding the universality of planet formation in different galactic contexts. More extension of research and analysis of the JWST data is expected to give insights on these processes and be instrumental in revising how planets form around the universe.

---